Flow Research,
Inc. 27 Water Street Wakefield, MA
01880 781-245-3200 Project team: Jesse Yoder PhD, Belinda Burum Ducker Research
Company, Inc. 6905 Telegraph
Road Suite 300 Bloomfield Hills,
MI 48301 248-644-0086 Project team:
Nick Limb, Scott Shober Josiah Waxman,
Lorena Ferrari
Published by

Ducker Research Company, Inc.
A Division of Ducker Worldwide
March
2003
Chapter Description Page
Number
One........................... Executive Summary..................................................................... 1-1
Vortex Flowmeters Provide Accurate and Reliable Flow
Measurement....................................................................................... 1-1
Overview............................................................................................. 1-4
A Complete Analysis of the Flowmeter Market..................................... 1-5
Study Objectives.................................................................................. 1-5
Methodology....................................................................................... 1-6
Supplier Input...................................................................................... 1-6
Supplier Analysis.................................................................................. 1-6
OEM and End-User Analysis............................................................... 1-8
Forecasts............................................................................................. 1-9
Definitions............................................................................................ 1-9
Paradigm Case Selection Method....................................................... 1-11
Growth Factors for the Vortex Flowmeter Market.............................. 1-13
Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Region...................... 1-14
Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Type........................ 1-14
Market Shares for Vortex Flowmeters by Geographic Region............. 1-15
Overview of Strategies....................................................................... 1-16
Vortex Meters: A Reliable and Versatile Meter at an Economical
Price.................................................................................................. 1-16
Consider Multivariable Vortex Flowmeters......................................... 1-17
Offer Vortex Flowmeters Designed for Specific Industries
and Applications................................................................................ 1-18
Chapter Description Page
Number
Two........................... Introduction and Methodology................................................... 2-1
Overview............................................................................................. 2-1
A Complete Analysis of the Flowmeter Market..................................... 2-2
The Role of Viewpoint Pluralism........................................................... 2-3
The Importance of Cross-Technology Research.................................... 2-5
Leading Suppliers vs. All Suppliers....................................................... 2-7
Study Objectives.................................................................................. 2-8
Methodology....................................................................................... 2-9
Supplier Input...................................................................................... 2-9
Supplier Analysis.................................................................................. 2-9
OEM and End-User Analysis............................................................. 2-11
Forecasts........................................................................................... 2-11
Definitions.......................................................................................... 2-12
Smart Flowmeters.............................................................................. 2-14
Communication Protocols................................................................... 2-15
Geographic Regions........................................................................... 2-19
End-User Industries........................................................................... 2-21
Vortex Flowmeter Industry Structure.................................................. 2-21
Team History and Experience............................................................. 2-21
Flow Research................................................................................... 2-22
Ducker Research............................................................................... 2-27
Custom Projects................................................................................ 2-28
Acknowledgement............................................................................. 2-28
Three........................ Vortex Flowmeter Product and Technology Analysis................ 3-1
New Technology Flowmeters............................................................... 3-2
Coriolis Flowmeters............................................................................. 3-3
Magnetic Flowmeters........................................................................... 3-5
Ultrasonic Flowmeters.......................................................................... 3-6
Vortex Flowmeters.............................................................................. 3-7
Paradigm Case Selection Method....................................................... 3-12
Vortex Flowmeter Product Analysis................................................... 3-15
ABB.................................................................................................. 3-16
Asahi America................................................................................... 3-18
Chapter Description Page
Number
3 (continued)
EMCO.............................................................................................. 3-19
Emerson Rosemount ......................................................................... 2-21
Endress & Hauser.............................................................................. 3-22
Foxboro............................................................................................ 3-24
Hangzhu Zhenhua Meter Company..................................................... 3-25
J-Tec................................................................................................. 3-26
Krohne.............................................................................................. 3-28
Oval.................................................................................................. 3-29
Sierra Instruments.............................................................................. 3-31
Tokyo Keiso...................................................................................... 3-32
Yokogawa......................................................................................... 3-34
Four.......................... Vortex Flowmeter Market Size and Forecast............................ 4-1
Overview............................................................................................. 4-1
Vortex Flowmeter Revenues Remain Flat Between 2000 and 2002....... 4-2
Vortex Flowmeters Provide Accurate and Reliable Flow
Measurement....................................................................................... 4-3
Growth Factors for the Vortex Flowmeter Market................................ 4-5
Flowmeter Factors............................................................................... 4-6
Vortex Flowmeters Offer a Reliable and Accurate Measurement
At a Competitive Price......................................................................... 4-6
Vortex Flowmeters are the Lowest Cost New Technology Meter......... 4-7
Vortex Flowmeters are Widely Used for Steam Applications................ 4-7
District Heating Applications Use Vortex Flowmeters........................... 4-8
More Suppliers Now in the Market...................................................... 4-8
Multivariable Vortex Flowmeters Now Available.................................. 4-9
Technological Improvements in Vortex Flowmeters............................. 4-10
Users are Moving Towards New Technology Meters......................... 4-10
Users are Looking for Low Maintenance............................................ 4-11
Custody Transfer of Natural Gas a Potential Market for Vortex
Meters............................................................................................... 4-12
The Advent of Foundation Fieldbus and Profibus................................ 4-13
Increased Use of HART..................................................................... 4-17
Factors Limiting the Growth of Vortex Flowmeters............................. 4-18
Chapter Description Page
Number
4 (continued)
The Inherently Conservative Nature of Users in the Process
Industries........................................................................................... 4-18
Measuring Low Flowrates.................................................................. 4-19
Competition From Other New Technology Flowmeters...................... 4-19
Market Size and Growth Forecasts.................................................... 4-20
Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Region:
Figures 4-1 to 4-5.............................................................................. 4-21
Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Type:
Figures 4-6 to 4-13............................................................................ 4-21
Average Selling Prices of Vortex Flowmeters:
Figures 4-14 to 4-16.......................................................................... 4-22
Shipments of Multivariable Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide
and by Region: Figures 4-17 to 4-21.................................................. 4-23
Shipments of Single-Variable Smart Vortex Flowmeters
Worldwide and by Region: Figures 4-22 to 4-26................................ 4-23
Shipments of Conventional Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide and
by Region: Figure 4-26 to 4-31.......................................................... 4-24
Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Fluid Type Worldwide and
by Region: Figures 4-32 to 4-38......................................................... 4-24
Shipments of Multivariable & Smart Vortex Flowmeters by
Communication Protocol: Figures 4-39 to 4-45.................................. 4-26
Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Industry:
Figures 4-46 to 4-51.......................................................................... 4-27
Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Distribution
Channels: Figures 4-52 to 4-54.......................................................... 4-28
Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide and by Region
by Customer Type: Figures 4-55 to 4-57............................................ 4-29
Chapter Description Page
Number
Five.......................... Vortex Flowmeter Supplier Market Shares............................... 5-1
Overview............................................................................................. 5-1
Market Shares for Vortex Flowmeters by Geographic Region:
Figures 5-1 to 5-6................................................................................ 5-1
Market Shares for Multivariable Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide:
Figure 5-7.......................................................................................... 5-11
Market Shares for Smart Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide:
Figure 5-8.......................................................................................... 5-11
Market Shares for Conventional Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide:
Figure 5-9.......................................................................................... 5-12
Market Shares for Vortex Flowmeters for Liquid Applications:
Figures 5-10 to 5-15.......................................................................... 5-12
Market Shares for Vortex Flowmeters for Steam Applications:
Figure 5-16........................................................................................ 5-13
Market Shares for Vortex Flowmeters for Gas Applications:
Figure 5-17........................................................................................ 5-14
Six............................ Strategies for Success................................................................. 6-1
Overview............................................................................................. 6-1
Vortex Meters: A Reliable and Versatile Meter at an
Economical Price................................................................................. 6-1
Tap Into the Fast-Growing Market for Gas Applications....................... 6-3
Pursue the Market for Steam Applications............................................ 6-3
Become a Broad-Line Supplier............................................................ 6-5
Offer a Variety of Models, Including Wafer, Flanged and
Insertion............................................................................................... 6-6
Form Alliances with Other Companies.................................................. 6-7
Emphasize the Advantages of Vortex Flowmeters................................. 6-8
Create a Coherent and Understandable Product Naming System........... 6-9
Build a Great Website........................................................................ 6-12
Educate Your Customers about Vortex Technology............................ 6-13
Invest in Smart Flowmeters, and in Communication Protocols............. 6-14
Chapter Description Page
Number
Seven....................... Vortex Flowmeter Supplier Profiles........................................... 7-1
ABB Automation................................................................................. 7-3
Asahi America, Inc............................................................................... 7-8
Eastech Flow Controls....................................................................... 7-10
EMCO.............................................................................................. 7-12
Emerson Rosemount, Inc.................................................................... 7-14
Endress & Hauser AG....................................................................... 7-22
Hangzhu Zhenhua Meter Factory........................................................ 7-26
Invensys Group Headquarters............................................................ 7-27
Foxboro............................................................................................ 7-27
Invensys Energy Metering (Invensys Metering Systems)...................... 7-30
J-Tec Associates................................................................................ 7-35
Krohne Messtechnik GmbH & Co. KG............................................. 7-37
Oval Corporation............................................................................... 7-41
Sierra Instruments, Inc........................................................................ 7-45
Tokyo Keiso Company, Ltd............................................................... 7-47
Yokogawa Electric Company............................................................. 7-49
Figure
Number Description Page
Number
1-1 Total Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide........................................... 1-19
1-2 Total Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide........................................... 1-20
1-3 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Region..................................................... 1-21
1-4 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Type........................................................ 1-22
1-5 Market Shares for the Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters
Worldwide...................................................................................................... 1-23
2-1 New Technology and Traditional Flowmeters................................................... 2-29
2-2 Flowmeters Offered by Vortex Flowmeter Suppliers........................................ 2-30
2-3 Models and Types of Vortex Flowmeters by Supplier....................................... 2-31
2-4
Communication Protocols Offered by Smart Vortex Flowmeter
Suppliers......................................................................................................... 2-32
2-5 Flowmeters Approved by the Fieldbus Foundation........................................... 2-33
3-1 ABB Vortex Flowmeters................................................................................. 3-17
3-2 Asahi America Vortex Flowmeters................................................................... 3-18
3-3 EMCO Vortex Flowmeters.............................................................................. 3-20
3-4 Emerson Rosemount Vortex Flowmeters.......................................................... 3.21
3-5 Endress & Hauser Vortex Flowmeters............................................................. 3-23
3-6 Foxboro Vortex Flowmeters............................................................................ 3-24
3-7 Hangzhu Zhenhua Vortex Flowmeters.............................................................. 3-25
3-8 J-Tec Vortex Flowmeters................................................................................ 3-27
3-9 Krohne Vortex Flowmeters.............................................................................. 3-28
3-10 Oval Vortex Flowmeters.................................................................................. 3-30
3-11 Sierra Vortex Flowmeters................................................................................ 3-31
3-12 Tokyo Keiso Vortex Flowmeters..................................................................... 3-33
3-13 Yokogowa Vortex Flowmeters........................................................................ 3-35
(continued)
Figure
Number Description Page
Number
4-1 Total Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide........................................... 4-31
4-2 Total Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide........................................... 4-32
4-3 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Region..................................................... 4-33
4-4 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Region..................................................... 4-34
4-5 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Region..................................................... 4-35
4-6 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Type...................................... 4-36
4-7 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Type...................................... 4-37
4-8 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Type...................................... 4-38
4-9 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Type in North America............................. 4-39
4-10 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Type in Europe......................................... 4-40
4-11 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Type in Japan........................................... 4-41
4-12 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Type in Asia w/o Japan............................ 4-42
4-13 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Type in Rest of World.............................. 4-43
4-14 Average Selling Price of Vortex Flowmeters by Region..................................... 4-44
4-15 Average Selling Price of Vortex Flowmeters by Type....................................... 4-45
4-16 Average Selling Price of Vortex Flowmeters..................................................... 4-46
4-17 Shipments of Multivariable Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide............................... 4-47
4-18 Shipments of Multivariable Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide............................... 4-48
4-19 Shipments of Multivariable Vortex Flowmeters by Region................................. 4-49
4-20 Shipments of Multivariable Vortex Flowmeters by Region................................. 4-50
4-21 Shipments of Multivariable Vortex Flowmeters by Region................................. 4-51
4-22 Shipments of Single Variable Smart Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide.................. 4-52
4-23 Shipments of Single Variable Smart Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide.................. 4-53
4-24 Shipments of Single Variable Smart Vortex Flowmeters by Region.................... 4-54
4-25 Shipments of Single Variable Smart Vortex Flowmeters by Region.................... 4-55
4-26 Shipments of Single Variable Smart Vortex Flowmeters by Region.................... 4-56
4-27 Shipments of Conventional Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide............................... 4-57
4-28 Shipments of Conventional Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide............................... 4-58
4-29 Shipments of Conventional Vortex Flowmeters by Region................................. 4-59
4-30 Shipments of Conventional Vortex Flowmeters by Region................................. 4-60
4-31 Shipments of Conventional Vortex Flowmeters by Region................................. 4-61
(continued)
Figure
Number Description Page
Number
4-32 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Fluid Type.............................. 4-62
4-33 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Fluid Type.............................. 4-63
4-34 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters in North America by Fluid Type.................... 4-64
4-35 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters in Europe by Fluid Type................................ 4-65
4-36 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters in Japan by Fluid Type.................................. 4-66
4-37 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters in Asia w/o Japan by Fluid Type.................... 4-67
4-38 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters in Rest of World by Fluid Type...................... 4-68
4-39
Shipments of Multivariable and Smart Vortex Flowmeters
Worldwide by
Communication Protocol.................................................................................. 4-69
4-40
Shipments of Multivariable and Smart Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide
by
Communication Protocol.................................................................................. 4-70
4-41
Shipments of Multivariable and Smart Vortex Flowmeters in
North
America by Communication Protocol............................................................... 4-71
4-42
Shipments of Multivariable and Smart Vortex Flowmeters in
Europe by
Communication Protocol.................................................................................. 4-72
4-43
Shipments of Multivariable and Smart Vortex Flowmeters in
Japan by
Communication Protocol.................................................................................. 4-73
4-44
Shipments of Multivariable and Smart Vortex Flowmeters in Asia
w/o
Japan by Communication Protocol................................................................... 4-74
4-45
Shipments of Multivariable and Smart Vortex Flowmeters in Rest
of World by World by Communication Protocol............................................... 4-75
4-46 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Industry.................................. 4-76
4-47 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters in North America by Industry........................ 4-77
4-48 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters in Europe by Industry.................................... 4-78
4-49 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters in Japan by Industry...................................... 4-79
4-50 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters in Asia w/o Japan by Industry........................ 4-80
4-51 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters in Rest of World by Industry.......................... 4-81
4-52 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Distribution Channel............... 4-82
4-53 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Region by Distribution Channel................. 4-83
4-54 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Region by Distribution Channel................. 4-84
4-55 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide by Customer Type...................... 4-85
4-56 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Region by Customer Type........................ 4-86
4-57 Shipments of Vortex Flowmeters by Region by Customer Type........................ 4-87
(continued)
Figure
Number Description Page
Number
5-1
Market Shares for the Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters
Worldwide...................................................................................................... 5-17
5-2
Market Shares for the Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters
in North America............................................................................................. 5-18
5-3 Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters in Europe.............. 5-19
5-4 Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters in Japan................ 5-20
5-5
Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters in
Asia
without Japan................................................................................................... 5-21
5-6
Market Shares for the Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters
in
Rest of World.................................................................................................. 5-22
5-7
Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Multivariable Vortex
Flowmeters
Worldwide...................................................................................................... 5-23
5-8
Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Smart Vortex Flowmeters
Worldwide...................................................................................................... 5-24
5-9 Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Conventional Vortex Flowmeters Worldwide 5-25
5-10
Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters for
Liquid
Applications Worldwide................................................................................... 5-26
5-11
Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters for
Liquid
Applications in North America......................................................................... 5-27
5-12
Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters for
Liquid
Applications in Europe..................................................................................... 5-28
5-13
Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters for
Liquid
Applications in Japan....................................................................................... 5-29
5-14
Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters for
Liquid
Applications in Asia without Japan.................................................................... 5-30
5-15
Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters for
Liquid
Applications in Rest of World........................................................................... 5-31
5-16
Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters for
Steam
Applications Worldwide................................................................................... 5-32
5-17
Market Shares for Leading Suppliers of Vortex Flowmeters for
Gas
Applications Worldwide................................................................................... 5-33
6-1 Become a Broad-Line Supplier........................................................................ 6-17
6-2 Offer Many Models and Types of Vortex Flowmeters...................................... 6-18
Table
Number Description Page
Number
3-1 Advantages and Disadvantages of DP and New Technology Flowmeters....... 3-9
3-2 New Technology and DP Flowmeters Principals of Operation..................... 3-11
3-3 Paradigm Case Conditions for New Technology Flowmeters....................... 3-13
4-1 Worldwide Average Selling Prices for Flowmeters........................................ 4-7
Photo
Number Description Page
Number
2-1 World Map................................................................................................ 2-20
3-1 ABB Swirl 4.............................................................................................. 3-17
3-2 ABB Vortex 4............................................................................................ 3-17
3-3 Asahi America Univeral Flowmeter............................................................. 3-18
3-4 EMCO Hydroflow Model 1200................................................................. 3-20
3-5 EMCO Hydroflow Model 2300................................................................. 3-20
3-6 EMCO PhD Vortex Flowmeter.................................................................. 3-20
3-7 EMCO V-Bar Insertion Flowmeter............................................................ 3-20
3-8 Emerson Rosemount Model 8800 C........................................................... 3-21
3-9 Endress & Hauser Prowirl 70..................................................................... 3-23
3-10 Endress & Hauser Prowirl 77..................................................................... 3-23
3-11 Endress & Hauser Vortex Flowmeters (Typical Products)........................... 3-23
3-12 Foxboro E83 Series................................................................................... 3-24
3-13 Hangzhu Zhenhua Vortex Flowmeters......................................................... 3-25
3-14 J-Tec V1800TR......................................................................................... 3-27
3-15 J-Tec VE500............................................................................................. 3-27
3-16 J-Tec VL600............................................................................................. 3-27
3-17 J-Tec VP700TS......................................................................................... 3-27
3-18 J-Tec VL650............................................................................................. 3-27
3-19 Krohne VFM 3100 (Flange)...................................................................... 3-28
3-20 Krohne VFM 3100 (Wafer)....................................................................... 3-28
3-21 Oval Ex-Delta (Fixed Sensor)..................................................................... 3-30
3-22 Oval Ex-Delta (Insertion-type).................................................................... 3-30
3-23 Oval Ex-Delta (Replaceable Sensor)........................................................... 3-30
3-24 Sierra Model 240-241............................................................................... 3-31
3-25 Sierra Series 220-221................................................................................ 3-31
3-26 Tokyo Keiso VF 2000 .............................................................................. 3-33
3-27 Tokyo Keiso VF 3000............................................................................... 3-33
3-28 Tokyo Keiso VF 4000............................................................................... 3-33
3-29 Yokogawa Typical YEWFLO Flowmeter................................................... 3-35